15th September 2010 O’Leary Analytics has published analysis today which shows the huge media interest in the Brian Cowen Interview with 457 articles published in less than 24 hours. At 8:50am on Tuesday 14th September 2010, Taoiseach Brian Cowen was interviewed by Cathal Mac Coille on Morning Ireland. The interview took place in the Ardilaun Hotel on the second day of the Fianna Fáil parliamentary party conference. Over the following 15 hours, the interview, and the performance of Mr Cowen during it, became an international news story.
O’Leary Analytics has analysed the coverage from over 128,000 news sources in over 200 countries in the 15 hours following the interview.
HIGHLIGHTS
Key highlights of the analysis include:
- The story has been appeared in publications in 26 countries including: USA, UK, India and China;
- Over 400 publications have covered the story;
- 457 articles were published by midnight on 14th September, less than 24 hours after the interview;
- The coverage appeared in leading international publications including: Reuters; The Wall Street Journal; The New York Times; The Washington Post; Fox News; The Guardian; The BBC; The Huffington Post; Yahoo! Finance;
- The coverage represented a 692% increase on the average daily coverage for Mr Cowen over the proceeding five days;
As the Taoiseach of Ireland, Mr Cowen is no stranger to publicity and media attention. On an average day, 60 articles are published online mentioning Mr Cowen, and for the most part, they relate to his political performances. Following the interview on Morning Ireland, however, this coverage spiked with 457 articles published yesterday.
SOCIAL MEDIA REACTION
O’Leary Analytics has also examined the level of coverage Mr Cowen generated in social media on the day of the interview. It revealed that there were:
- 1,738 mentions of Mr Cowen in social media sources on the day;
- Twitter was the most popular social media platform with over 1,600 Tweets published;
- Simon Coveney’s initial Tweet was ReTweeted (republished word for word) by over 66 other Twitter accounts.
- Mr Coveney was not the first person to suggest Mr Cowen was drunk or hungover during his interview – dozens of tweets were published while the interview was taking place questioning the performance of Mr Cowen and suggesting reasons for his performance.
MONITORING
This research demonstrates that Irish political parties and Fianna Fáil specifically have failed to understand social media and it’s potential benefits and pitfalls. That the Taoiseach could be unaware of an incendiary tweet from a member of the opposition front bench indicates that Fainna Fáil does not monitor social media. Had the Taoiseach been aware of Deputy Coveney and others online comments about his early morning interview, he would surely have been prepared for questions from journalists as to whether he was drunk or hungover.
LESSON LEARNED?
The lesson here for all political parties is that digital media is equally critical to their success or failure as traditional print and broadcast channels.
We live in an era of 24/7 news reporting, where a story can break at any given time during the day and can spread like wildfire due to the Internet. Companies, organizations, individuals, even governments are increasingly concerned about what is being said about them in real time. As a result they have to respond quickly because a story can evolve rapidly as we have seen in recent cases such as the Ivor Callely expenses scandal or the revelations surrounding Wayne Rooney. With regards to this story, it will be interesting to see how the global markets respond as our analysis shows this has become an international media issue





[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Barry, Stephen O'Leary, EmilyAM, Stephen O'Leary, Lydia Murphy and others. Lydia Murphy said: RT @stephenoleary: Latest Analysis from @OLearyAnalytics – The Brian Cowen Interview: The Global Media Response http://bit.ly/9Ak1ND [...]
[...] Analytics have produced an interesting analysis of the social media response to the latest ‘Cowengate‘ or ‘Gargle-gate‘ as [...]
Very good article Stephen. Right to point out that Simon Coveney’s tweet was not by any means the first.
I am not sure about FF being unaware though. If that was me in Cowen’s shoes I would have feigned a lack of awareness of the tweet as a means of suggesting it was of no consequence, and obviously had no truth to it.
If he admitted to being aware of it, the accusation could be that he was more concerned with the views of social media commentators than with the real business of getting the country out of it’s mess.
Interesting that by the time of the evening bulletins, most of the comments to shows like the Last Word were suggesting that this was all being blown up and that opposition and the media should be concentrating on the real issues of jobs and Anglo and the IMF.
Excellent coverage thanks. Too much media attention is my opinion as per my blog post on http://www.sonru.com/blog/article/brian_cowen_interview_on_morning_ireland_alternative_ending/
Excellent piece of analysis and it surprised me to see that there were more mentions of the Cowen crisis in the USA than Ireland. The original interview can be downloaded from the RTE site – it was in the second hour of Morning Ireland on the 14th : http://www.rte.ie/radio1/podcast/podcast_morningireland.xml
In the midst of the follow up coverage today it was good to hear you included with Fintan O’Toole and Noel Whelan on ‘Today with Pat Kenny’. The lack of knowledge of some of the social media ‘experts’ consulted by the media is appalling but Pat Kenny knows how to choose his pundits!
[...] What’s clear from this is that Simon Coveney did not start this storm. His profile as a TD may have amplified it, but he only said what people were already thinking, tweeting, and talking to each other about in workplaces all over …. [...]
It was reported on RTE news last night that this time last year Mr. Cowen gave a similar interview. What has changed in the last 12 months to make it news worthy story, Twitter, our confidence or otherwise in our public representatives, the sensitivity towards how others outside Ireland may have of us? Whatever the reason we all need to raise our game considerably for us to come out of this crisis hopefully wiser and more chastened
Pity the opposition(Fine Gael) have to stoop so low as to call the Taosach drunk, they must be really getting desperate.
Simon Coveney should look into his own closet before calling names.
Now let us look at Mr.Coveney…………………………..
he………..
Whether or not Mr. Coveney was first to raise doubts about Mr. Cowen’s performance, and whether or not Mr. Cowen was genuinely hoarse, or hoarse out of his mind, it was Mr. Coveney that escalated this to the international media. That does absolutely nothing for the country.
But then, Simon Coveney? Fine Gael? So what’s new!
Great analysis Stephen. A perfect story to illustrate how social communication now defines the world and the stories around us. Someone with a twitter account in west cork can be as powerful as a journalist sitting in a studio.
Thanks for sharing this,
Micha
Nice post Stephen.
I noted yesterday that FF were subtly inferring that Simon Coveney was being less than patriotic by pouring petrol on the beginnings of this fire.
Those FFers may get encouragement from this post that shows how far the word spread and the potential damage it has caused Ireland in terms of
-how it further weakens the perception of Ireland’s economy and how it’s being managed
- how it reinforces the racial stereotype of Ireland being a nation of hardened drinkers
That said, if you step back a bit the real lesson here is for our current and future leaders. Gone are the days when our mini national crises can be ring-fenced within the 26/32 counties. The power of the internet and more particularly social media means that the reputation of countries and individuals can be damaged in a matter of hours.
Simon Coveney’s “OMG” Twitter moment is the real embarrassment here. It’s amazing how low a politician will stoop to get attention!
Only in Ireland would the national leader think it is appropriate to stay up drinking and engaging in a ‘sing song’ until 3.30 in the morning when he was scheduled to address the nation at 8.45 am the following morning about the worst crisis in the history of the state.
It speaks volumes about the reasons why Ireland ‘is where it is’ that the average Irish citizen thinks ‘What’s the big deal?’
So What!!! Our leader was out enjoying himself, maybe had a little too much to drink, and made a bad interview! Did he kill or maim anyone? NO! Did he put anyone in jepardy? NO! He has a very tough job, and God help us if the opposition gets in! Id rahter a drunk Brian Cowan running the country than a sober Enda Kenny!!!
Excellent analysis, Steve. I’m in Chicago and just listened to the interview. In my view it’s been completely blown out of proportion – and this analysis is incredibly interesting. Well done.
Kev
The world wide web,and its ancillary forms of communication, will-if it retains freedom of speech, and information,and censorship by nation states-will hopefully be a force for fundamental change.
Fantastic insights steve
Great analysis Stephen, really interesting read!
In a nod to history the triumphant Fianna Fail strategy meeting ended with a good old knees up. It’s an awful shame that some new songs hadn’t been commissioned. After all in bygone years we could have denounced our imperial neighbors for all our woes with “Four Green Fields” perhaps now we need some aspiring composers to give us an update along the lines of “Four Development Plots and all of them in Nama”
Such a sorry state of affairs and who has got us into the mess. Well as far as I can tell it’s the very same politicians from Fianna Fail who think it’s OK to have a good old party while reviewing the disastrous state of the nation. Nero fiddles anyone?
I don’t care what anybody says it is a complete disgrace and an embarrassment to all Irish people but particularly those of us living abroad and reading the headlines in the International press. I can only thank our lucky stars that Brian Cowan and his merry band of cronies cancelled their (second) trip to China last week. With all the baijiu and KTV halls here they might never have made it home.
Stephen,
Any chance of a list of the Irish sites?
Also, I’m wondering what constitutes a news source? 100+ Irish news sites being updated within 12 hours seems very high…
Mark
just a query Re your analysis.
81 hits on Facebook. Why so low? I can get you 43 status updates amoung my friends alone who mentioned Cowen. Also are you just looking for mentions of the word “Cowen”. Did you go through each mention to ensure it was relevant? All comments may not have been negative.
also be interesting for a breakdown on websites you use for your country by country graph.
Really interesting analysis Steve and thanks for highlighting the way that social media can grip the globe with what some pundits consider interesting and/or important. It is also extremely sad that other incidents that affect peoples lives in a more fundamental way do not get the same emphasis.
Hi Donal,
Thanks for the comments and the questions. Re facebook – we don’t monitor status updates on personal profiles – that information, no matter what the individual users privacy settings – is not available to be searched. Each mention we found was made on a public forum within Facebook such as a group.
Re: the keywords used in the social media search – we cross referenced for relevance – but we did not analyse the sentiment.
Hi Mark,
Thanks for the questions. I can send you on a full list of the Irish news sources quoted in the analysis, drop me a quick email.
Really interesting analysis Stephen.
[...] the situation from a PR point of view and indeed from an online PR perspective – particularly by O’Leary Analytics whose in-depth report just goes to show the power of Twitter and the the impact of a social media [...]
stephen – an interesting side effect of all this is the rise in public awareness of Simon Coveney. there was a short lived meme on twitter called #simoncoveneysfault that played on the FF strategy of attacking/blaming Mr Coveney.
I cant asertain if this has been beneficial to Mr Coveney – but it certainly has raised his profile in a big way.